Yes I hope so.
I don’t know why the yes water based caused so much pain. But won’t use the water based again.
That was terrifying it felt like I had not been on estrogen this morning and back when I was on absolutely
Not sure if anyone here uses ChatGPT but it gave me some answers:
see below I didn’t know about #2 and #4 but I feel that is what was going on.
It seems like your body might be reacting strongly to Yes Water-Based because of a few key factors related to your current vaginal health:
1. pH Sensitivity
The pH of Yes WB is around 4, which is considered normal for the vagina, but if your tissues are already thin, dry, or inflamed, they may be more sensitive to changes in pH. Even a slight shift could cause discomfort or irritation, especially if your vaginal tissues are more vulnerable due to perimenopause and hormonal changes.
2. Osmolality Mismatch
Water-based products like Yes WB often have a higher osmolality, which means they could draw moisture out of your vaginal tissues instead of providing it. Since your tissues are already compromised due to vaginal atrophy, this can lead to a painful or stinging sensation, especially if your body isn’t able to retain enough moisture.
3. Ingredient Sensitivity
Even though Yes WB is made with natural ingredients, preservatives like potassium sorbate or glycerin (in some formulations) can sometimes irritate sensitive tissues. If your skin is already thin or damaged, it’s more likely to react to something that wouldn’t normally cause irritation.
4. Underlying Inflammation
If your vaginal lining is already inflamed or has microtears from dryness, any product—especially a water-based one—can feel too intense. Water-based products can sometimes feel harsh, as they tend to evaporate quickly and may leave the tissues feeling dry afterward.
5. Barrier Protection
With vaginal atrophy, your tissue’s protective barrier is weakened. This makes it more sensitive to external products, and even mild products can cause discomfort if they interact with your delicate tissues.
What you can do:
Given your reaction, sticking with an oil-based product like Yes OB or something more natural (like coconut oil or emu oil) could be gentler and better for your sensitive tissues. Oil-based moisturizers tend to stay longer, hydrate deeply, and aren’t as likely to irritate.
Thought I would share the feedback from it