Hi glass.half.full - a girl after my own heart
It depends where you were in menopause when you started HRT 5 years ago. I mean if you were already peri and skipping periods etc you would hope that they would not necessarily return with quite the same frequency after 5 years.
Are you saying that you had your first period 1 month after stopping and then the second after another month and then middle of the third month?
What HRT were you on? How your body is reacting depends to some extent on what you were taking and of course where in menopause. If you are still having regular (normal) periods then you are still very much peri-menopausal and as such your symptoms may come back. However the bleeding could be eg due to a thickened womb lining built up while you were taking HRT or possibly fibroids that have grown?
You are only just at the average age of menopause so you may well still have periods for a while yet.
Depending on what you were taking and where you were in meno when starting hRT - keep an eye on it and do not hesitate to go back to the doc if the bleeding continues and uf you are at all worried that it seems abnormal or unexpected. Anything goes in peri-menopause - but you don't really know if this bleeding is normal or not for you, without a quick medical check...
Hurdity x