This is a really interesting question, Sooby and the other ladies' answers are along the lines of what I feel. Whilst I would always recommend to someone who is desperately trying to control SEVERE meno symptoms to consider HRT, by consider it I simply mean take time to learn about it, weigh up the benefits & risks and don't be rushed or pressured into the choice by anyone. You have already been there and know how HRT made you feel. I sense that you are happy with who you are now and THIS is surely the most important thing. It may be that you and those around you just need a little more time to see what is the new normal, but I would not bend to accommodate others' wishes if you yourself are content without HRT.
Though it seems to help many ladies, HRT is not a cure-all for everyone and for many it seems to be about weighing up whether or not the side effects are tolerable for the benefits it brings. Starting HRT was a very difficult decision for me and whilst I am better on it than without, it has not resolved all my symptoms. If I felt I could get by without it, I would, but having taken the decision to start I want to give it a reasonable trial for now and hope I will find a better fit that will enable me to gain better quality of life for the future. If so, I aim to stay on it as long as possible, but this is because symptoms went on so long before I started it that it seemed my body was NEVER going to be able to manage without it. Since starting HRT I have also been diagnosed with osteopenia, so this makes it sensible to continue if I can.
Babyjane & I both have thyroid conditions and I respect her view and think she was very wise to grit her teeth and push through without HRT, as it can be the very devil to juggle with other interacting meds & managing a thyroid condition can be hard enough in itself. I would never have started HRT, with a family history of breast cancer & other medical reasons not to, had I not been absolutely desperate, after many years of extreme symptoms (on top of chronic pain) that had virtually wrecked my life.
In your shoes, I think I would stand your ground - menopause can make us so unsure of so many things, but given time you should know whether or not you have made the right decision and if not too old, can perhaps give HRT another go, should YOU decide you might be better with it than without. It is your life and no-one else has the right to make this important decision for you.
