Menopause Matters Forum
Menopause Discussion => All things menopause => Topic started by: Chi chi on October 31, 2016, 10:11:56 AM
-
Last time I posted I had decided to come off HRT as I didn't think it was actually improving anything, I have since gone back on it ::) i think I lasted maybe a couple of weeks without?
I'm now wondering if Tibolone would be an option for me? As some may know I've been on oestrogel (4 pumps) testosterone and utrogestan for approx 3 yrs now with very little change in symptoms :-\
I've tried different birth control pills none of which helped and some actually made things worse!
I feel like I'm no further forward with HRT and just can't tolerate the prog part.
I'm prob clutching at straws but at this moment in time I'm willing to try anything!
I'm 42 and a smoker my main symptoms are low moods, anxiety, aches and pains, loss of libido, dryness down below, practically everything BUT the flushes.
-
Chi chi, I would say that tibolone is definitely worth a try. It has a steroid type hormone which apparently produces some testosterone. A doctor I met in Spain thinks it's great and it is widely used there. I haven't tried it myself because of my migraines but I have been tempted.
One added bonus, it is bleed free! So give it a try and please report back with you findings.
Good luck!
-
Thanks MaryG,
I just wonder how is it "different" to regular HRT? How can it help if bio HRT hasn't?
-
Chi chi, perhaps this product will succeed where others have failed because if its steroid content. I'm no expert but I believe tibolone is different from other types of HRT so you have nothing to lose by trying it. Many women take it for years.
Just out of interest, do you think you other regime would have worked if you hadn't had to take the dreaded progesterone?
-
I've changed to Tibolone 2 weeks ago and feel a lot better. Try it and see. You can always go back if it doesn't help.
-
Chi Chi - Tibolone works in a very different way to normal HRT and, when I tried it, I found it great - my only real problem was the acne - I already suffer with spots (even now) so unfortunately the Tibolone made it far worse. EVen Utrogestan made me come up in rashes on my face!!! Tibolone will be well worth trying - it worked great for the flushes within a few days and I slept like a baby at night - felt generally good apart from the horrible spots. DG x
-
Thanks everyone :) I just wasn't sure if it would be a possibility for me as I don't do well on any kind of prog (even the Mirena) and as its synthetic I thought it would be the same as birth control pills which I can't take as I'm a smoker.
MaryG- I'm not sure as for most of the time I've been on HRT I've only had a few goes with the utrogestan which have left me feeling low for months after! :-\
-
Chi Chi - Tibolone isn't a progesterone so could be a good things to try. DG x
-
Hi Chi Chi - I was on hols with a group of women last year and one of them was on Tibolone - she absolutely raved about it, said she'd never felt better. I'm really interested in this as I too have had the gel, T, utrogestan combo for over a year and apart from moving to equivalent dose patches, I'm still using the same protocol with very meh! results. Like you, I don't have the daytime flushes, but everything else, in fact, joint pain is worse!
Please report your findings if you decide on this route.
Dxx
-
I've just read that it's only for woman who have been through the menopause?? Is this right? :-\
-
I had 6 months on Tibolone and felt great other than headaches which is why I stopped. I was gutted as really improved my energy levels and hot flushes etc. I had to take it in the morning otherwise it did keep me awake. I've now started on oestrogel and no headaches but definitely doesn't give me the get up and go Tibolone did!
I've started on testosterone gel yesterday so hoping this will give me a boost!
My understanding of Tibolone was it was for after hysterectomy or post menopause but I could be wrong?!
Definitely worth a go if you're offered it though.
X
-
Yes Chi chi as Otes73 confirms, it is chiefly for post-menopausal women as it is a no-bleed HRT. There is another thread on this just started by Sooze in Personal Experiences:
http://www.menopausematters.co.uk/forum/index.php/topic,33626.0.html
Here is the product info on it:
http://www.medicines.org.uk/emc/medicine/8552
This is taken from the mode of action section:
"Following oral administration, tibolone is rapidly metabolised into three compounds, which all contribute to the pharmacodynamic profile of Livial. Two of the metabolites (3α-OH-tibolone and 3β-OH-tibolone) have oestrogenic-like activities, whereas the third metabolite (Δ4-isomer of tibolone) has progestogenic and androgenic-like activities.
Livial substitutes for the loss of oestrogen production in postmenopausal women and alleviates menopausal symptoms. Livial prevents bone loss following menopause or ovariectomy."
One side effect is thickening of the uterus.
From the same document:
"The available data from randomised controlled trials are conflicting; however, observational studies have consistently shown that women who are prescribed Livial in normal clinical practice are at an increased risk of having endometrial cancer diagnosed (see also section 4.8). In these studies risk increased with increasing duration of use. Tibolone increases endometrial wall thickness, as measured by transvaginal ultrasound."
I don't think it is suitable for you as you are still peri-menopausal?.
Hurdity x
-
Oh what a pity Hurdity - I thought it provided progestogenic effects too. Apparently not. Does that mean you'd have to take additional prog?
Dxx
-
Just my luck! ::) :-\
-
Dawncam, you don't need to take progesterone with Livial (tibolone). Many women take it for years without having any problems so don't be scared off if you feel like giving it a try. My gynaecologist has mentioned that she has quite a few patients who take it.
Chi chi, where are you in the menopause? Is it worth running the tibolone idea past a specialist anyway just to get their opinion? You are a patient of Professor Studd I think? Because you can't take any progesterone at all and have reached the end of the road on this, why not at least get some professional advice and if they say no, you haven't lost anything by asking.
-
Hi Dawncam - as Mary G says - you don't take progestogen with it. The description says the third metabolite of tibolone is a compound with "progestogenic and androgenic-like activities". However even though no progestogen is taken with it, due to the increased risk of endometrial thickening on it, personally I would only take this is if I could get an annual uterine scan on NHS - which is not unreasonable given it is stated in the product info and also in the product monograph I looked at too. That was my one concern. Hundreds of women are happily taking it though! Before starting testosterone I was considering this although would have totally gone against my nil-by-mouth approach to HRT!
Hurdity x
-
Mmmm.. interesting though
Dxx
-
Could it be said it's safer than bhrt?
Dxx
-
Taken from Prof Studd's website, didn't say only woman who have gone through the menopause?
Women may wish to avoid bleeding by using low dose oestrogen and progestogen or by the use of Tibolone or they may wish to have a Mirena IUS inserted.
-
Here is the link which discusses this in full - so not to be read in isolation:
http://www.studd.co.uk/var_summary.php
The section you quoted from is entitled "Variations on HRT" and is prefaced by the paragraph:
"The principles of hormone therapy for the menopausal or perimenopausal woman can be summarized thus. These items are not entirely consistent with the current advice of regulatory bodies but they do reflect a studied analysis of the available data as well as a long clinical and academic interest in the subject. Medical practitioners of all levels require guidance for the hormonal treatment of middle aged women. These views should be considered, discussed and criticised as a fresh clinical approach is urgently needed. Currently many women suffering severe hormonal disorders are being needlessly denied appropriate safe hormone therapy"
So he is saying these should be considered but they are not the norm. He goes on to list the ways in which he proposes deviating from the standard/licensed doses and treatments (including the 7 day progesterone often quoted on here).
I think you are/have been a patient of his so by all means ask at your next appointment - and as it is non-standard would require supervision - and presumably he will have observations from patients to back this up or predict what the outcomes would be for some women who are not yet at menopause?
Hurdity x