Menopause Matters Forum
Menopause Discussion => Other Health Discussion => Topic started by: English Rose on September 15, 2013, 10:46:51 AM
-
Hi ladies
Has anyone on the forum tried taking digestive enzymes (you can buy them from health shops) for IBS/indigestion symptoms; and if so how did you get on with them?
Thanks in advance, ER x
-
I think before you put anything into your gut you need to speak with a Dietician ;-). What exactly are digestive enzymes ........... probiotics etc. have been researched thoroughly so the ins and outs are known.
If you have continual indigestion you need to see your GP. IBS can cover a multitude of symptoms, sadly - it can be Trial and Error to find something that helps. Some things have to be taken regularly and some can be short-term, used as necessary.
I find that for indigestion Rennies or such like help. For the IBS I drink Actimel. My GP gave me in 1998 a set course of medication which I HAD to take within the hour of my main meals in order for it to work. Colpermin capsules for upper gut wind, Maxillon (I think) for encouraging the gut spasm to move food through. As an anorexic my gut had stopped working almost completely!!!! It took 3 months before I began to feel well again.
A proper diganosis for gut problems is essential. At 'our' time of Life hiatus hernia is a common problem and can be controlled by certain medication. Do go to your GP before yous pend out in a Health Shop. Once you have a diagnosis and find something that eases symptoms you can explore 'other' stuff.
-
There is rarely a quick fix!
-
Sunday Science Lesson CLKD http://www.bbc.co.uk/learningzone/clips/digestive-enzymes/10649.html
Taz ;)
-
:thankyou: Teacher - YUK ;-) ;D
-
Digestive enzyme supplements are used a lot in children on the autistic spectrum and my friend who died from pancreatic cancer this year also had to use them following the Whipples procedure he had to undergo. :(
Taz x
-
Does the patient need the gut contents analysing in order to replace the 'correct' enzymes?
-
I have a friend with IBS and she uses them when she is eating at friends or restaurants with great success.
-
No you don't have to give a sample. I think that with children on the autistic spectrum a normal amount of digestive enzymes is not enough so supplementation is to boost the numbers already present. I've never really followed this up properly I must admit.
Taz
-
Interesting. How does not having enough enzymes affect the children?
-
It's quite complicated but there is a bit of an explanation here http://www.care2.com/greenliving/enzyme-therapy-for-autism.html
Taz x
-
Thanks for the responses.
I am sure you mean well CLKD but I am not in need of advice re: going to the doctor, I am perfectly capable and have already sought medical advice on this matter from my extremely knowledgeable GP and a gastroenterologist.
I was just interested to know if anyone has tried digestive enzymes as I understand it is a theory that digestive problems including IBS/indigestion in mid-life can be due to ageing of the pancreas and a reduction in secretions/enzymes.
Thanks for the clip Taz. Sorry to hear about your friend; very sad. Winterose - interesting that your friend found them helpful for IBS, I'm thinking of giving them a try. Nothing ventured, nothing gained.
All the best, ER. x
-
" ........ I am not in need of advice re: going to the doctor, I am perfectly capable ........ "
sorry I spoke :'(
-
Thanks for the responses.
I am sure you mean well CLKD but I am not in need of advice re: going to the doctor, I am perfectly capable and have already sought medical advice
"Has anyone on the forum tried taking digestive enzymes (you can buy them from health shops) for IBS/indigestion symptoms"
Sounded like a request for comment or opinion..........
-
Hello CLKD
No need for apologies; I was just asking for womens' experiences with taking digestive enzymes - I was not in need of any personal health advice - perhaps I did not make this clear enough.
Best wishes, ER.
-
I took digestive enzymes a few years ago following the advice of a nutritionist. Apparently I had 'leaky gut syndrome', meaning I couldn't break down the nutrients of food efficiently, as I had insufficient enzymes in my gut. At the time I couldn't keep the weight on. Now I can.....very efficiently...... middle age spread! I would take advice, as the enzymes were just part of the dietary support I needed.
-
Hi Ju Ju
Thank you for the information. How did you manage to get your "leaky gut" diagnosis and did the enzymes help? Sounds like you're not taking them now.
I'm currently reading a book on the subject by a US nutrition expert (Susan Lark) who advocates healthy eating too with lots of fruit and vegetables.
I've had lots of tests which show nothing amiss and diagnosis always comes back to IBS; and I'm not losing weight (also middle aged spread I'm afraid!), but I'm very interested by this theory about enzymes - makes sense that as we age our digestive system is less able to break down foods efficiently.
All the best, ER.
-
I saw a very good nutritionist, but it was expensive. My poo was sent off to a lab in the USA for analysis! I had various infections and parasites. All very nasty, but with treatment, they were cleared only to be replaced with new ones.
When I stopped working, I could no longer afford to carry on with this treatment and I wasn't feeling any better, so I felt disheartened. Bear in mind I have had IBS symptoms since childhood and I felt something else was going on.
I have since sought help from a therapist and did a course with a life coach, which have been very beneficial, even if I still have IBS symptoms. IBS along with other illnesses have an emotional and environmental background. Symptoms are very real.... says I after a long session in the loo!
I think seeking help from a nutritionist can be very helpful, but not without looking at emotional issues as well. When planning meals, I was advised to start with the veg, protein next and last carbs. Eat smaller portions, but more often. Never eat a meal without protein. Avoid processed food as far as possible and cut out sugar and artificial sweeteners which are worse.
Right I'm off to follow my own advice and lose my unwanted weight......after finishing the naughty things in my cupboard! :-\
-
Hi JuJu
Thanks....so the enzymes didn't help your IBS then? (if I understood you correctly).
I have heard of food combining...talks about that in the book I'm reading. Re emotions: I think my IBS can be triggered by tiredness / work stress but not always....sometimes just happens for no apparent reason.
IBS is more prevalent in affluent western countries apparently - something to do with our rich often unhealthy diet and use of processed foods.
All the best, ER x
-
I'm not sure how helpful the digestive enzymes were. They were part of a variety of treatments. I believe they are helpful for other people. I think my IBS is part of a bigger picture. I was seeking a medical solution and wasn't prepared to look at the emotional background. I would like to go back to the nutritionist I saw at some future date.
I believe IBS set in after gastric enteritis at a time of trauma. Apparently, this isn't unusual. I didn't realise that other people didn't have to cope with what I was experiencing. Only recently have I talked about it, only to realise how common it has become. I had a healthy diet as a child, post war, cooked from scratch. I suspect, like asthma, it has always been about, but far more prevalent due to diet, environmental issues eg pollution, pesticides.
-
I think my IBS developed through an over use of PPIs. Long term use can cause bowel problems. It was exacerbated by meno.
I always had bowel problems when I had a period.
I got good advice and alternative therapies from Jan de Vries who is local to me. He is well respected and is excellent. Through his medicine and HRT I have gone from a limited diet to one where I can eat most things. I have blips and have to resort to main stream remedies but usually get it back under control. I had the D type IBS and it ruled my life. Things are much better now.
Honeyb
X
-
Honeybun, (love the name!)
I'd be interested in what alternative therapies you tried. I'm still on a limited diet, although it has eased up a bit.
Ju Ju
-
The remedies I take are herbal from A Vogel.
I take Centaurium before a meal. This stimulates the digestive process.
Also Tormentil if I have the horrid washing machine sounding stomach and or the runs.
Also Iberogast for upset stomach and nausea.
I also take a pro biotic every day.
Tormentil is also an anti spasmodic which can help with pain.
It's not a quick fix. I think it took me about six weeks or so to feel the full benefit.
The alternative practitioner that I use also has a help line with great staff who can advise you and also sell you products.
Hope this helps.
Honeyb
X
-
Thanks. I have heard of A Vogel and will look into it when I can afford to. I am seeing a therapist and have Body Stress Release as well, but this adds up financially. I think what I am doing at the moment is helpful and will make me more receptive.
I hope English Rose or the regal ER isn't put off digestive enzymes, as used with other supplements such as probiotics. I think the symptoms vary from person to person and is diagnosed by elimination of other conditions. I joined the Gut Trust (I think they changed their name since) a few years ago. They have plenty of useful information and advice.
-
The supplements are not that expensive. Usually between eight or nine pounds and they last for months. I have a Google to see who has the best deals on and order accordingly. It's trial and error with stomach things and we are all different. I used to have such a strong stomach. I could eat anything and everything until my third pregnancy and had such bad heartburn my stomach never really recovered. I was then given increasingly stronger medication until my stomach forgot how to work for itself. It was a case of retraining.
Hope what you are doing now works for you.
Honeyb
X
-
Er.
My friend who takes these is only 25 and just started a month ago , will update you when I see her, know she doesnt take them all the time but maybe one could ?
-
Hello all
Honeyb - I agree with you about PPI's. I tried them for a short while and they made me feel yuk. At the end of the day they prevent your body from making digestive juices/ acids needed for digestion of foods so this feels counter-intuitive for me. I've had IBS since my twenties.
No I'm not put off digestive enzymes Ju Ju, I started taking them a few days ago before meals (found some good chewable ones mixed with a probiotic) and so far, so good. Much less indigestion up to now anyway. I have read lots of reviews on the internet........majority seem very positive. I will check out the Gut Trust too (now known as the IBS Network it seems; lots of helpful info on their website about IBS in general).
Winterose - thanks for the update on your friend, I am glad she has found something to help. I think you can take them up to 3 times a day with meals but I guess it's trial and error as to how much/little an individual needs to take.
Best wishes, ER x (NOT the royal one, ha, ha ;) )
-
I didn't think that an apology was required :sigh: (sorry I spoke) - this is after all, a discussion Forum :-\
-
I can see you were only trying to help clkd, but i think English rose meant that she didnt need or want personal advice, re going to drs etc.. she just wanted specific info, comments, advice on the enzyme question... x
-
It's easy for a post to be misconstrued. Now we know that English Rose had already consulted a doctor but from the original post this was not clear.
IBS Network link for anyone who needs more advice/info http://www.theibsnetwork.org/
Taz